Sauce Up Extra Spicy Chili Crisp Review

This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission if you buy through them — at no extra cost to you. My scores are never influenced by this.

Sauce Up Extra Spicy Chili Crisp Review — The Hotter Sibling

This Sauce Up Extra Spicy chili crisp review covers the second jar I’ve opened from the NYC lineup. Sauce Up NYC makes their chili crisp in New York City, and I reviewed the Original already — liked the grapeseed oil base, liked the shallot-forward flavor, thought it landed at GOOD without pushing higher. The Extra Spicy uses the same ingredient list with what I assume are adjusted proportions to crank the heat. Same 6-ounce jar, same $14.99 price point, same label typos.

The question with any “extra spicy” variant is whether the heat adds to the product or just sits on top of it. Sauce Up’s Original was mild enough that more heat sounded like a good idea. I wanted to see if the extra fire brought the formula up or just made it louder.

Quick Facts

Serving size is one tablespoon — I like that. Honest portion. One gram of added sugar per serving, which is the same as the Original and the White Truffle. Comes from the coconut sugar in the ingredient list.

Ingredient Quality

The full ingredient list: grapeseed oil, dried red chilies, coconut sugar, fried shallot, white sesame seed, fried garlic, Himalayan sea salt, ground shiitake mushrooms, ground seaweed, umami powder (not MSG), ground ginger.

It’s the same build as the Original. Grapeseed oil leading is a deliberate choice — it’s a neutral, higher smoke-point oil that lets the other ingredients do the talking. No soybean oil, no canola. I respect that.

Dried red chilies sitting second tells you where the heat is coming from, and the proportions here are clearly adjusted from the Original to push the spice level. Coconut sugar at number three explains the sweetness I taste up front. Fried shallot and fried garlic are the crunch backbone — same as the Original, and they work.

The bottom of the list is where it gets interesting. Ground shiitake mushrooms, ground seaweed, and umami powder — Sauce Up explicitly says “not MSG” on the label, which is a marketing choice more than a flavor one. The umami is coming from these three ingredients working together. Ground ginger at the very end punches above its position on the label — you can taste it in the sweetness.

Label claims are extensive: paleo, vegan, gluten-free, nut-free, keto, no GMO, no HFCS, no dairy, no preservatives. Contains sesame. The label itself still has the same typos and run-on sentences as the rest of the Sauce Up line. They weren’t expecting anyone to actually read it closely.

Aroma

Smells very similar to the Original on open — that warm shallot-and-sesame base is the Sauce Up signature. But there’s more chili coming through on the nose here. Not sharp or aggressive, just present. You can tell the dried red chili ratio is higher before you taste anything.

Appearance and Settlement

Dark red oil — darker than the Original. You can’t really see down through it, which tells you the chili infusion is heavier. When I mixed it, quite a few bits came up. Finely ground powdery elements in the oil itself, plus visible fried shallot, fried garlic, and sesame seeds. The fine grind means some of the flavor is suspended in the oil rather than sitting as discrete chunks.

The fork sat before stirring, which is a good sign for bit density. This isn’t a jar where the fork drops straight to the bottom.

Texture and Crunch

The crunchy bits are tasty. Fried shallot and garlic provide the primary crunch, with sesame seeds adding a secondary texture. The crunch holds up — not soggy, not chewy. The bits are on the smaller side, which works fine on food.

There’s a decent amount of solid material in this jar. The fine-ground shiitake and seaweed powder adds body to the oil without contributing visible chunks, so the texture feels denser than it looks. When you pull a fork through it, the oil clings and the bits come with it.

Flavor Complexity

There are layers to this chili crisp — they just don’t arrive at the same time.

First bite: sweetness up front. Coconut sugar and ginger hit immediately, along with the crunch. Umami from the shiitake-seaweed-umami powder trio shows up right behind it. For about three seconds, this tastes like a sweeter, more interesting version of the Original. The grapeseed oil is clean — no greasy film, no off-notes. It lets the shallot and garlic come through without interference.

Then the heat arrives. Not immediately — there’s a gap. The sweetness starts to fade, and the cayenne-style burn starts building from the back. It’s a slow, deliberate ramp that eventually fills your entire mouth. Comes through the nose, covers the tongue, hits the top of the mouth. And then the sweetness is gone and the heat is running the show.

This is a split-jar situation. The oil is doing real flavor work — you can taste the chili infusion and the shallot sweetness when you try the oil alone. But the “whole jar” experience gets fractured by the heat timeline. The complexity is there in the ingredient list and in the first few seconds of each bite. The heat just buries it.

For a spice lover, that’s not necessarily a problem. If you’re reaching for “extra spicy,” you want the heat to be the headline. And it is.

Heat

This is a straight cayenne-style burn — no Sichuan peppercorn tingle, no numbing, no mala character. Just heat. It builds slowly from nothing, peaks about 15–20 seconds in, and stays. I was still feeling it a full two minutes after my last bite.

The burn is full-mouth: tongue, roof of the mouth, through the nose. It’s not a front-of-lips sting or a back-of-throat scratch. It fills the space. For my palate, this is a solid 4 out of 5 — genuinely hot, not a marketing exaggeration. If you have moderate spice tolerance, you’ll feel this. If you have low tolerance, this jar isn’t for you.

The issue isn’t the intensity — it’s the timing. The heat arrives on a completely separate schedule from the sweetness and umami. They don’t overlap. You get the flavor first, then the heat takes over alone. I wish the heat showed up a little sooner so everything could hit together and feel more balanced. As it stands, the capsaicin burn is kind of distracting from the flavors that are actually there.

Use Cases

This jar works best on food that can absorb and distribute the heat. Rice, noodles, scrambled eggs — anything with mass to spread the burn across. I wouldn’t put this on something delicate. A piece of fish or a light salad would get overwhelmed.

Where it really makes sense: anything that’s already flavorful but needs a heat boost. Chicken stir-fry that came out a little flat. Ramen that needs an extra kick. Pizza, if you’re the type who puts chili crisp on pizza (I am). The sweetness from the coconut sugar and ginger actually works in those contexts because the food’s own flavors fill the gap between the sweet hit and the heat hit.

The Mixing Angle

This is a mixing candidate. Specifically, I’d mix it with the Sauce Up Original. Same flavor DNA, same oil base, same shallot-garlic backbone — but the Original is mild enough that blending the two lets you dial in exactly how much heat you want. Eat half the Original, add a few spoonfuls of this, stir it up. You get the full Sauce Up flavor profile at whatever heat level works for you.

Versatility and Packaging

Same 6-ounce jar as the rest of the Sauce Up line. At $14.99, that’s $2.50 per ounce — on the pricier side for a 6-ounce jar, but in line with small-batch American-made chili crisps. If you buy the 3-pack with the Original and White Truffle, the per-jar cost drops.

The jar opens fine, spoon access is good, lid seals cleanly. No complaints on the packaging side. The label is still a mess — typos, a run-on sentence in the mission statement — but the product inside is better than the label suggests.

Benchmark Comparison

Against Lao Gan Ma as the baseline: the Sauce Up Extra Spicy is hotter, has a cleaner oil (grapeseed vs. soybean), and the crunchy bits are tastier. But LGM gives you more complexity from the fermented black beans and Sichuan peppercorns — there’s a fruitiness and depth to LGM’s flavor that Sauce Up doesn’t match. The Extra Spicy’s heat is one-dimensional in comparison. It’s just burn, where LGM’s heat has character.

Against the Sauce Up Original: same product, louder. The Original’s mild heat let the sweetness, umami, and shallot flavors stay in the conversation the whole time. The Extra Spicy has all of those same flavors — they just get shouted over by the second act. If you liked the Original and want more heat, this is exactly that. If you liked the Original because it was balanced, this trades balance for fire.

Final Verdict — GOOD

Sauce Up Extra Spicy is a good jar for people who want heat with substance behind it. The grapeseed oil is clean, the crunchy bits deliver, the umami-shallot-ginger base is genuinely interesting — and then the cayenne burn takes over and runs the show for the next two minutes. The flavors are there. They just don’t get to finish their sentence before the heat interrupts.

For spice lovers, this is worth buying. The heat is real, the ingredients are honest, and you’re getting a well-made product from a small NYC operation. For everyone else, the Original gives you the same formula without the fire. Either way, Sauce Up knows what they’re doing — they just might not know how to proofread a label.

Tier: GOOD

Buy Sauce Up Extra Spicy on Amazon